Concepts: questions and answers

To exit this page click on the X in the top right corner.

by Gilbert Pleuger (Editor of new perspective)

Article titles are in red. Scroll down until you reach the relevant title

 

Socialism

Q1. What were the two influences that prompted the growth of socialism?

A1. (a) Liberalism and capitalism supported political and economic freedom which defended the subordination of the working class. (b) The French Revolution had released the ideas of liberty, equality and fraternity which could not be attained under other ideologies.

Q2. What did socialist hold could not be left to individual initiative after the development of industrialisation?

A2. The integration and control of the economy and society.

Q3. What did Robert Owen and Saint-Simon claim socialism could eradicate?

A3. Endemic (that is, deep-set) poverty, exploitation and crime by planning and by co-operation within factories,

Q4. When did socialist ideas spread in London and Paris?

A4. In the 1840s

Q5. What did reformist socialism become when it started to be more threatening to capitalism?

A5. Revolutionary socialism.

Q6. What did latter-day, extreme, socialism claim capitalism had done to the working class during the creation of great wealth?

A6. Impoverished and brutalised industrial workers (the proletariat)

Q7. What did Karl Marx claim formed working-class views of politics, morals and so on?

A7. Working-class views were a reflection of their economic and social position.

Q8. What did Marx predict for the capitalist system?

A8. Its collapse, because of internal contradictions, and the triumph of the working class.

Q9. What was Marx’s legacy to socialism?

A9. Increased vigour to socialist thought, greater theoretical depth and support to a wide range of socialist programmes.

Q10. What did all socialists share in common?

A10. A rejection of a narrowly political view of freedom.
 

Communism

Q1. Which is the ideology from which modern communism is seen as an off shoot?

A1. Socialism.

Q2. What is the two-part essence of communism?

A2. (a) abolition of private property and (b) dependence of individuals on the community.

Q3. While communism is often thought to be the offshoot of socialism,
      how far back can communist ideas be traced?
A3. To Plato, in The Republic. Early Christian groups and the monastic had communist beliefs.
Q4. What are two essences of the communist idea?
A4. 1. The complete dependence of the individual on the community.
      2. The abolition of private property.
Q5. What was ‘the twist’ that Marx gave to communist ideology?
A5. Marx claimed that communist society was an inevitable in an industrial capitalist society.
      For Marx, collective ownership was a necessary complement to ‘the complex interrelationships
      of industrial society’.
Q6. What did Marx claim even after the 1840s?
A6. The establishment of communism would end coercive political institutions.
Q7. When, and why, did Marx introduce the idea of a temporary ‘dictatorship of the proletariat’.
A7. Marx introduced this idea in the later nineteenth century when there had been no major revolution.
Q8. Who used the idea of dictatorship of the proletariat and how did he use it?
A8. Lenin adapted the idea to justify a vanguard party to control the direction of affairs
      and raise the political awareness of workers and peasants.
Q9. What should communism as an ideology not be identified with?
A9. The Soviet Regime.

 

Élites

Q1. What is (a) the original and (b) the modern (from the nineteenth century) meaning of élite?

A1. (a) a person chosen, either elected or selected; (b) a ruling group in society.

Q2. What ideas are élites and élitism opposed to?

A2. Equality and pluralist ideas power

Q3. What do élites claim?

A3. Superiority of proven ability, skill, character, birth or education.

Q4. Can there be élites in any social or cultural group?

A4. Yes.

Q5. Which sort of élite particularly interest historians?

A5. Political élites.

Q6. What are the characteristics of élites?

A6. Organisation, mutual support, exclusiveness, anti-democratic and anti-socialist convictions, belief in superiority of own qualities and abilities.

Q7. What are the two key questions about an élite from a political point of view?

A7. How the élite is selected and how open the élite is to new talent.

Q8. Does non recognition of élites and élitism support non recognition of superiority?

A8. No.
 

Historical facts

Q1. What initial definition does the author, in his discussion, give to fact?

A1. Either a true proposition (that is, statement) or a real state of affairs that correspond to a proposition.

Q2. What is the complication brought out by the example of the execution of Charles I?

A2. Facts are irrespective of time and place.

Q3. Name two ways the word fact is used.

A3. (a) to give emphasis (b) as equivalent to a true proposition.

Q4. What are the two aspects of fact?

A4. The world aspect and the word aspect.

Q5. What does the historian need to use as he works to establish ‘facts’?

A5. Judgement must be used which, because historians study the past, is dependant on evidence.
 

Imperialism

Q1. What is a concise definition of imperialism?

A1. ‘The exercise of power by one state or one people over another.’

Q2. Name some other types of imperialism, other than that of governance?

A2. Economic, cultural imperialism.

Q3. What is the key characteristic to note when referring to any type of imperialism?

A3. Effective domination.

Q4. When was the ‘classic’ age of imperialism?

A4. The later years of the nineteenth and earlier years of the twentieth centuries.

Q5. What was (a) key and (b) what was not fundamental in this process?

A5. (a) attitudes  (b) quantities of people or territories incorporated into an empire.

Q6. What benefits for the imperial power did supporters of imperialism claim?

A6. Wealth from trade, power from the control of territory, moral improvement of ‘natives’ by the spread of culture.

Q7. How did Marxists view imperialism?

A7. The reflection of the needs of business and financial interests to gain more outlets for trade supported by political influence leading to domination.

Q8. Identify (a) a general and (b) a particular meaning of imperialism.

A8. (a) domination over others - relates to any period of history. (b) particular to the later nineteenth century, the practice of domination and/or attitudes and political programmes and, sometimes, developments within economies in the home country.
 

Hegemony

Q1. What did hegemony originally mean and what does it mean today?
A1. It originally meant ‘to lead’ but today it refers to the dominance of certain specified ideas.
Q2. What did Antonio Gramsci claim?
A2. A politically dominant group will be, also and necessarily, ideologically dominate: those dominated
      will accept the moral and intellectual leadership of the politically leading group.
Q3. Assuming that there is a connection between intellectual and political dominance, which,
      according to Gramsci, comes first?
A3. Intellectual dominance.
Q4. What did Karl Marx in A Critique of Political Economy, 1859, claim determined the consciousness of Man?
A4. Marx claimed that the consciousness of Man is their social being, especially the means of production.
Q5. How did Gramsci modify the Marxist view expressed in A Critique of Political Economy?
A5. Gramsci claimed it was not only a society’s means of production but also ideas that form Mans consciousness.
 

Revolution

Q1. By which date was revolution used to describe the complete overthrow of a government?

A1. 1600.

Q2. What had revolution described before this date?

A2. (a) astronomical movement and (b) a great change in circumstances.

Q3. When did writers begin to use revolution to describe social and economic events?

A3. In the late nineteenth century.

Q4. What characteristics must a revolution have to distinguish it from a mere change?

A4. It must have either great speed and/or great extent of change or a great number of people affected or a great degree to which people and their lives are affected.

Q5. How many types of revolution are there, according to Leiden and Schmitt?

A5. 5.

Q6. How many stages are there in any political revolution, according to Leiden and Schmitt?

A6. 3.

Q7. What role does a concept, such as revolution, play in a history writer’s account?

A7. A series of events is labelled and used as a short hand to facilitate a description and analysis of the past.
 

Power

Q1. What is a synonym for power?

A1. Influence.

Q2. Is power, that is a power relationship, absent from any area of life?

A2. No, as long are there is more than one person present.

Q3. How may expressions of power are described by the author?

A3. 5.

Q4. How is political power defined?

A4. Activity which has any bearing on the making or implementation of decisions (for the protection, ordering or well-being of society).

Q5. Why is a stylised depiction of government insufficient for a sure understanding of government?

A5. It is insufficient because the real working of government is far more complicated and subtle than a diagram can portray.

Q6. What is social power?

A6. It is any influence which changes the characteristics of a group or its relations with other groups.

Q7. What is economic power?

A7. Economic power is influence by a person or group of people on the production and distribution of goods and services.
 

Nationalism

Q1. When did nationalism become a political force

A1. After the French Revolution.

Q2.What do nationalists in any society on?

A2. The identity of the nation confers value on the state.

Q3. Why can it be claimed that nationalism is the most effective modern ideology?

A3. Because of its capacity to mobilise populations.

Q4. What are the roots of nationalism?

A4. The roots of nationalism are cultural, a fostering of local culture, especially language, in opposition to the influence of local culture(s).

Q5. What stimulated the growth of politics ???

A5. The return of dynastic politics in 1815.

Q6. What was the range of the political dominance of nationalism?

A6. It ranged from direct democracy to extreme forms of authoritarian rule.

Q7. What was the consequence of this range?

A7. It increased the appeal of nationalism.

Q8. Why would nationalism appeal to rulers?

A8. Through their identification with the state as a symbol of the nation,  a sense of political participation could be attained without any real real extension of popular involvement in government.

Q9. What became more likely after the identification of the interests of the State with the needs of the nation?

A9. The change from the probability of a world of diverse nations living in harmony to a world I which a nation is justified in asserting it self against other nations.
 

Society

Q1. What can society refer to?

A1. Society can refer to either all the citizens of a state or to a group within a state who are identified by a common characteristic or interest or by the relation of that group to other groups within the state.

Q2. What types of criteria have been used to identify a subdivision of the citizens of a state?

A2. Wealth/income, type of employment, education, leisure activities, political affiliation.

Q3. What interests historians about a social group?

A3. The distinguishing characteristics, behaviour and views of the group and relationships with other groups.

Q4. What helps a more secure categorisation of society?

A4. Statistical information helps toward a more secure categorisation of society.

Q5. Why is an understanding of society helpful to political history?

A5. It helps to explain why political events happen. Society and the economy are the slower moving substrata which form the foundation on which politics are conducted.
 

Dictatorship

Q1. Who identified key features of dictatorship in the fourth century BC?

A1. Aristotle in The Politics and Plato in The Republic.

Q2. What was dictatorship in the Roman Empire and when and how was it established?
A2. During a time of emergency the Senate appointed a man to hold absolute
      (unrestricted) power for a period of 7 year.
Q3. What does dictatorship refer to after the French Revolution?
A3. A form of government in which one person is so dominant that there is no effective opposition through
      alternative power centre and which the rule of law (please see rule of law concept) is absent.
Q4. What do more complete modern dictatorship embody?
A4. Totalitarianism (please see totalitarianism concept)
Q5. After constitutionally achieved additions to power what was the key to Hitler’s extension of dictatorial power?

A5.
Q6. What was the key to Stalin’s establishment of dictatorship?
A6. Within the political structure created by Lenin, the establishment of clientage among party members
    by careful appointment through his office as General Secretary of the Communist Party.
Q7. What are the 6 criteria that can be used to assess the degree of dictatorship?
A7. 1 An ideology to which adherence is demanded.
      2 A mass party which is interwoven with a state bureaucracy
      3 Exclusive control of the armed forces
      4 Exclusive control over the media and mass communication
      5 A secret police force
      6 Central control over the economy
 

Keynesianism

Q1. What is macroeconomic theory and policy?
A1. The theory of the working of the overall economy and the policy means to maintain economic stability.
Q2. What were the five main propositions of Keynes in The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1935)
A2. 1 Capitalist markets have no natural tendency to maintain equilibrium at full employment.
      2 There is a difference between voluntary and involuntary unemployment
      3 A lack of total spending was the reason Keynes gave for involuntary unemployment
      4 Private, that is non government, spending was the primary reason for a lack of total spending
      5 Government could (and should) step in to make good a shortfall in total spending
Q3. What did Keynes’ theory imply for government?
A3. Keynes’s theory implied a large role for government activity and a substantial involvement in the working of the (macro) economy.
Q4. In which period was Keynes’s greatest influence?
A4. In the post-war world, from 1945 until the 1960s.
 

Whig History

Q1. What did Macaulay claim in The History of England from the Accession of James II?
A1. He claimed that the last 160 marked the physical, moral and intellectual improvement of the English people.
Q2. What did Butterfield, by his Whig Interpretation of History, discourage in History writing?
A2. Butterfield discouraged books with a broad narrative and straightforward explanations of events.
Q3. What were the four main characteristics of Whig History identified by Butterfield?
A3. 1 Views of the past were influenced by the political needs of the present and the history writer’s views.
      2 Characteristic No 1 led to assumptions on the ‘direction’ of history
      3 Whig historians tend to overemphasise similarities between past and present and
         to applaud those who favoured ‘progress’.
      4 Whig historians tended to make moral judgements about people in the past.
Q4. Why did Butterfield oppose History writing that implied political philosophies as the ultimate goal in history?
A4. Butterfield, as a Christian, with a Christian’s worldview, disagreed with any worldview
      in which Man, not God, was the shaper of Man’s destiny.
 

Balance of power

Q1. How did Palmerston explain the rationale of the idea of the balance of power?

A1. ‘… it was in the interests of the community of nations that no nation shall acquire such a preponderance as to endanger the security of the rest.’

Q2.To which time have historians traced the use of the term to?

A2. To Guicciadini’s History of Italy published in 1561.

Q3. What event led to the questioning of the idea that the interest of the individual states and the state system as a whole was always irreconcilable?

A3. The partition of Poland in the eighteenth century.

Q4. In which nineteenth-century congress was the balance of power the guide to decisions?

A4. The Congress of Vienna in 1815, which met after the defeat of Napoleon.

Q5. What development in the middle of the nineteenth century led to the adjustment of inter-state relations?

A5. German and Italian nation state building

Q6. What was the League of Nations created to do?

A6. To provide an alternative to power politics.

Q7. After which date did a balance of power in Europe become part of a global balance of power?

A7. After 1945.
 

The Cold War

Q1. What are the two key parts of the concept of the Cold War?

A1. Intense mutual hostility and opposed ideology

Q2. What key words define each of the four characteristics of Cold War as described by Anders Stephenson?

A2.  A rivalry between two great blocs superimposed on the whole world

       B all means, short of war itself

       C denial of the others right to exist

       D suppression of internal dissidence

Q3. By which date were the two opposing ideologies of the Cold War in place?

A3.B y 1918.

Q4. What created the political context for the Cold War?

A4. The defeat of Nazi Germany in 1945

Q5. What were, in the view of some historians, the main phases of the Cold War?

A5.   1 1947-53

        2 1953-8

        3 1958-63

        4 1963 to the late 1970s

        5 The late 1970s to 1989/90
 

Economic autarky

Q1. What is the essence of autarchy?

A1. Self sufficiency

Q2. When did the idea of economic autarchy originate in Germany?

A2. After the 1918 defeat.

Q3. What does Wehrwirtshaft mean?

A3. A defence-led economy.

Q4. When did secret rearmament begin in Germany?

A4. After 1924 with the establishment in the German Army of an Economics Staff
 

Nazi Gleichschaltung

Q1. To what do totalitarian political systems aspire?

A1. The control of hearts and minds and blurring the difference between truth and falsehood so that the people can be fully manipulated by the government.

Q2. What is the literal translation of gleichschaltung?

A2. Literally, ‘switching onto the same track or wavelength’ or, more generally, alignment and co-ordination.

Q3. What was the use of the term gleichschaltung meant to achieve?

A3. To gloss over the use of terror and violence.

Q4. What was the focus in the early months of the Nazi regime?

A4. What was good for the Volk: the Fuhrer was the judge of this.
 

Constitution

Q1. What is a constitution?

A1. The structure of government, usually defined in a document.

Q2. When did several governments begin to change from absolutism to representative government?

A2. In the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries.

Q3. Which group of people used the call for constitutions to further their ambitions?

A3. Wealthier men who sort a share in the government process.

Q4. Why are constitutions, while formal definitions of power, insufficient to describe the operation of a system of government?

A4. Informal influence will effect a system of government. The 1936 USSR constitution and Bismarck’s Second Empire constitution, 1871, are examples.
 

Keynesianism versus Monetarism

Q1. What was Keynes’ book called and when was it published?

A1. The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, published in 1935

Q2. What is macroeconomic theory and policy?

A2. The theory of the overall working of the economy and of the policy policy maesures to maintain economic stability.

Q3. What did Keynes deny?

A3. He denied that capitalist economies corrected themselves to maintain stability without government intervention.

Q4. What, according to Keynes, was the reason for the failure to maintain full employment?

A4. A lack of total spending, mainly due to a shortfall in investment and that this could be corrected by the government.

Q5. When was the period of Keynes’ greatest influence?

A5. From 1945 until the latter 1960s.

Q6. What is the monetarist’s central claim?

A6. Money is the key to the level of prices.

Q7. What, according to monetarists, would influence output and the standard of living?

A7. Supply side economics.
 

Welfare State

Q1. What is a synonym for welfare?

A1. Well being

Q2. Which party introduced the Welfare State?

A2. The Labour administrations of 1945-51.

Q3. What was the blueprint for fr the Welfare State?

A3. The 1942 Beveridge Report

Q4. What were the five aims of the Welfare State?

A4. The abolition of want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness.

Q5. Which two parties were to co-operate in the Welfare State?

A5. The State and the individual.

Q6. Which was the key measure for the Welfare State?

A6. The National Insurance Act, 1946

Q7. What were payments by the state made for?

A7. Unemployment, sickness, maternity and funerals.

Q8. What was the name of the act, passed in 1948, that was complementary and key to the working of the Welfare State?

A8. The National Health Act

Q9. When was the Welfare State inaugurated, by whom and in which manner?

A9. On 5 July 1948, by the Prime Minister, Clement Attlee, in a radio broadcast.

Q10. What was the key, earlier, act related to the Welfare State which was a foundation for later developments?

A10. The National Insurance Act, 1911, passed by the Liberal administration.
 

Totalitarianism

Q1. When did the term totalitarianism gain wider currency?
A1. During the post-Second World War period of Cold War
Q2. Why is the theoretical model of totalitarianism proposed by Friedrich and Brzezinski helpful to students of History?
A2. The theoretical model provides a yardstick by which differences in form and degrees of extent may be made of a totalitarian state that has ‘a system of rule, driven by ideology, that seeks direction of all aspects of public activity, political, economic and social, and uses to that end, at least to a degree, propaganda and terror’.
Q3. What circumstances need to exist for liberal democracy to develop?
A3. For liberal democracy to develop the needs to be a degree of industrialisation, an active media and expressions and discussions of opinion in addition to attitudes held in common in society of tolerance and respect for minorities and individual rights and the absence of fixed goals.
Q4. If totalitarian rule operates within the same circumstances as liberal democracy, what are the essential differences to liberal-democratic rule?
A4. The key difference is the presence of fixed goals and activity to negate the attitudes that underpin liberal-democratic rule, activity that includes action against dissidents
 

Thatcherism

Q1. In relation to economics, what policies were Thatcher’s Chancellors often more enthusiastic to follow than she herself?
A1. Thatcher’s Chancellors were often more enthusiastic to cut taxes and pursue monetarist policies.
Q2. What were two deep-rooted objectives of Premier Thatcher to help ‘change the soul’?
A2. Premier Thatcher attempted to ‘unleash individual initiative of the British people’ by ‘rolling back the frontiers of the state’ and curbing the collective power exercised by trade unions.
Q3. What did Thatcherism become synonymous with by the mid-80s?
A3. Thatcherism, after the Falklands War and defeat of the miner’s Union (1984/5) became synonymous and the achievement of a high-degree of personal dominance by Mrs Thatcher, Thatcherism became synonymous with confrontation.
Q4. What are at least two significant questions on which Premier Thatcher will be judged in future assessments?
A4. Mrs Thatcher will be judged by the extent that her governments created a more self-reliant society and the extent to which she created an enterprise economy.
Q5. What are the two key reasons why it is inaccurate to call Thatcherism an ideology?
A5. The two key reasons are that its principles were neither clear nor consistent.
Q6. If Thatcherism was not an ideology how best can it be depicted?
A6. It is best depicted as a style of leadership.
 

The Europeam Union

Q1. Pending

A1. Pending
 

The rule of law

Q1. How do citizens have (personal) security under the rule of war?
A1. The enforcement of law is fair and not arbitrary.
Q2. What are the three essences of the rule of law as defined by A.V. Dicey in 1855?
A2. 1 Citizens are answerable only to ‘regular’ law and not the arbitrary decisions of officials and wide discretionary powers
2 Disputes between citizens and officials were subject to the ordinary courts
3 Citizens fundamental rights rested on ordinary law not on special, constitutional guarantees.
Q3. What two principles do contemporary versions of the rule of law stress?
A3. The two principles stressed are 1 Discretionary powers of rule making and adjudication should be by impartial tribunals. 2 Citizens should have clear guidance on their rights and duties.
Q4. Bearing in mind the criticisms of Dicey’s definition and its later amendments, what two features are considered essential to achieve and defend the rule of law?
A4. The two features are 1 The independence of the judiciary and 2 The written definition of constitutional rights.
Q5. When must the State be ruthless and violent?
A5. At times of social collapse and extensive terror.
Q6. What are the poles between which Man in political society needs to find balance?
A6. The poles are the liberty of citizens and government repression.
 

Propaganda

Q1. Why does propaganda work?
A1. Propaganda works because most people are not politically literate and accept guidance or simple recognition devices to make sense of political activity: they accept the claimed-for orthodoxy that is presented to them.
Q2. Why is it difficult to assess the effectiveness of propaganda?
A2. It is difficult to assess because there is a lack of clear evidence.
Q3. What is the key to the concept of propaganda?
A3. Persuasion is the key to the propaganda concept. It can make the worse reason appear the better, as Plato said of rhetoric. Propaganda is a mixture of myth, symbolism and rhetoric.
Q4. What are the four main categories of propaganda?
A4. 1 Explicit propaganda;
2 Entertainment;
3 Black propaganda;
4 Counter-propaganda.
Q5. Why should historians be particularly alert to propaganda?
A5. Historians be particularly alert to propaganda because propaganda can be used to ‘rewrite’ History by the leaders of any age.


Capitalism
Q1. What is the essence of capitalism?
A1. The productive use of surplus to generate further surplus.
Q2. What are the preconditions of the capitalist economic form?
A2. 1 A surplus
2 Citizen’s rights to private property
3 A market that enables the sale and purchase of goods and services
Q3. What are the three divisions that can be made for the concept of capitalism?
A3. 1 Capital goods, such as machines.
2 Money, that is working capital.
3 Human capital, that is the skills and knowledge of individuals.
Q4. What led to a huge expansion of manufacture and commercial capitalism in the mid-eighteenth century?
A4. Changes in production in manufacture and agriculture that we now term the agricultural and industrial revolutions.
Q5. Which writers and thinkers, in particular, provoked an ideological debate about a century ago?
A5. Karl Marx, author of Das Kapital (1867) and The Manifesto of the Communist Party (1848).
Q6. What do socialists celebrate but liberals deplore?
A6. The interference of the State in individual and economic activity.


Collective security
Q1. Is the concept of collective security new?
A1. No, it stretches ‘time put of mind’, for example, to the fifth century BC
Q2. Which event provoked the contemporary notion of collective security, with its emphasis on ‘collective’?
A2. The First world war.
Q3. What is the key characteristic of the contemporary expression of collective security and what is the name of the first institution that embodies that change?
A3. The key characteristic is wider international involvement, as illustrated by the League of Nations and, subsequently, the United Nations.
Q4. What were the four main weaknesses of the League of Nations?
A4. 1 Weaknesses in procedure
2 Non-participation of some of the major powers.
3 Absence of permanent meetings
4 Lack of military force
Q5. When and where was the form of the United Nations agreed?
A5. In 1944 at Dumbarton Oaks, Washington DC
Q6. What are the three key strengths of the UN compared to the League of Nations?
A6. 1 Security Council in permanent session
2 Major powers are members of the Security Council
3 Security Council decisions are binding on all members
4 UN military force enabled
Q7. What is one suggested reason for the absence of war between the major powers after 1945?
A7. The suggested reason is the balance of nuclear threat between the major (nuclear) powers.
 

Culture

Q1. From which century was the concept of culture used with increased frequency?
A1. The concept was used with increased frequency from the nineteenth century.
Q2. What is the meaning of the concept in its widest sense?
A2. It refers to all aspects of society, ‘all the activities and objects that mark the life of Man beyond just staying alive’.
Q3. Why is an appreciation of a society’s culture important for historians and History students?
A3. Culture describes a society’s particular ‘tone and colour’, it unearths and brings to attention ‘the beliefs, attitudes and values that lie below the surface of everyday life’ and it helps toward a surer understanding of the meaning of documents and, thereby, events.
Q4. What, loosely, is the distinction between high and low culture?
A4. High culture requires educational and attainment, low culture requires only participation.
Q5. What is role of culture for a society and, thereby, its importance?
A5. Culture constitutes a common yet distinctive identity that fosters a sense of belonging within a society.
Q6. How has the use of the concept of culture changes over the last decades?
A6. It is now used as a description for the mindset of a subgroup within society as illustrated by the phrase ‘enterprise culture …’.