Comments on how to use this site  for teachers  for students  |  About new perspective   |  Explore the Study Centre 
A Licence is so cost effective
 
|  Order form  Gain a FREE Licence  Amazing!  What you gain for only £9.40
www.history-ontheweb.co.uk

Start  I  The Study Centre  I   About new perspective and e-new perspective  Advanced History students' study guide  
Exam and study advice for AS/A Modern History  I  Topic guides  I  Core concepts  I  The world of sources
Guide to History degree course selection   I  History and theory  I  New texts from publishers
  I  GCSE Resource bank

 

The 1917 Russian Revolutions 
by Alf Wilkinson
NOF Internet Training Officer

The nature of the topic

Until fairly recently this topic has tended to be obscured by politics. Marxist historians tended to see the events in Russia up to and including 1917 in a very different light to non-Marxist historians. Soviet historians had a different view altogether! Since the end of the Soviet Union, and the opening up of Russian archives to Western historians it has become possible to look at the topic more objectively. I’m sure many major revelations will emerge.

Vital first steps

Make sure you know the start points and end points of your particular specification - some include 1905, some don’t; some continue to 1921, others stop at 1917. Find out which topics are regarded as central, and likely to figure in an exam, and which are regarded as background supporting knowledge. You will need to be able to put the topic clearly into context to do well in an exam. What will you be asked to do in the exam? Are you expected to recall factual knowledge, analyse sources or interpret historians’ views? This will influence how you prepare.

Fundamental issues

a. Why was there so much unrest in Russia? Romanovs had ruled Russia for 300 years - why were they now faced with such unrest? What were the fundamental reasons for demands for change? Who wanted change? Who supported the Tsar?

b. The Revolution of 1905. Immediate causes, and longer-term causes? Why was the Tsar able to reassert control in 1906? Was it a revolution? What changed? What stayed the same?

c. The impact of the First World War. Economic and political dislocation. Why did Russia fail so badly in the War? How did this affect morale of the troops and at home? Why was there growing discontent?

d. Short-term causes of the February Revolution. The Tsarina and Rasputin. The hard winter of 1916. Food and fuel shortages. Strikes in Petrograd and Moscow. Why did the political élite abandon the Tsar?

e. The failures of the Provisional Government. Who was in the Provisional Government? What did the Provisional Government have to offer? Why did support fade so rapidly during 1917?

f. The Bolshevik seizure of power in October 1917. The July Days, Kornilov and Kerensky. Why did support for the Bolsheviks increase so much between the two revolutions? The Soviets. What part was played by Lenin and Trotsky? The Constituent Assembly elections.

g. How the Bolsheviks kept power. Popular support, or lack of an alternative? Brest-Litovsk. How ruthless were the Bolsheviks in their desire to keep power? Did Lenin deliberately provoke the Civil War to keep power?

High-grade issues

a. Was the Tsar responsible for the Revolution? Was he a weak man who was determined to maintain the autocracy? Could other policies have prevented revolution? Or was the Tsar a good leader who managed to hold together a diverse Empire for so long?

b. Could the reforms of Witte and Stolypin have saved the Romanov dynasty? Economic and social reforms made great progress between 1907 and 1914 - can you have such reforms and maintain the political status quo? Or was it a case of ‘much too little, too late’?

c. Did the war cause the Revolution? Some historians argue the reforms were working, that the regime was on the way to ‘safety’, when war came and it so disrupted society it caused revolution. Others argue the war delayed revolution. The economy seemed to cope quite well initially, it was the infrastructure that failed. Certainly it was the conviction that the war could not be won with the Tsar as leader that led to his removal.

d. Could the Provisional Government have survived? Initially well supported, was it only hatred of Tsarism that kept everyone together? What mandate did it have? What mistakes were made? Why did it keep delaying elections? Why did it lose support?

e. How important was the role of Lenin? After February most Bolsheviks were co-operating with Mensheviks and SRs. How important was the ‘April Theses’ in establishing a clear policy? How did Lenin manage to drive through the Revolution against the wishes of many party members?

f. Coup d’état or popular revolution? How much support did the Bolsheviks have in October? Was it a popular revolution as Bolshevik propaganda maintained, or a coup - one minority government replacing another? How far was the ‘storming of the Winter Palace’ myth and how much fact? Who supported the Bolsheviks? Was it a change for a socialist government or a desire for stability after the recent months’ chaos?

g. Just how important was the role of revolutionaries in the Russian Revolution? Again, here it is sometimes difficult to separate propaganda from fact. There was undoubtedly a great demand for change, and all revolutionary parties grew in size during 1917. But just how influential revolutionary parties were is a matter of great debate.

Further Reading. Articles in new perspective: ‘Reflections on the Russian Revolution of 1917 in a Post-Communist World’ by Beryl Williams, Vol 1, No 2; ‘The Fall of the Romanovs’ by Maureen Perrie, Vol 2, No 3; ‘The Russian Revolution of February 1917: The Question of Organisation’ by Dr James D. White, Vol 3, No 2; ‘Interpreting Lenin in the Post-Leninist World’ by Dr Christopher Read, Vol 4, No 1; ‘Rasputin and the Decline of Tsarism’ by Dr Harold Shukman, Vol 6, No 1; ‘Why did Tsarist government not learn the lessons of the 1905 revolution?’ by Professor Peter Waldron, Vol 6, No 3; ‘Counterfactual History: the role of Lenin in 1917’ by Dr Ronald Kowalski, Vol 7, No 1. Texts: The first seven chapters of Peter Oxley’s new textbook Russia 1855-1991: From Tsars to Commissars, Oxford University Press, 2001, are an excellent starting point. The Historical Associations’ Between the Revolutions, Russia 1905 to 1917 by R.B. McKean is a short text carefully putting the events of 1917 into context. You might also find useful Sheila Fitzpatrick, The Russian Revolution, Steve Phillip’s Lenin and the Russian Revolution (Heinemann - Advanced History series) and Christopher Read’s From Tsar to Soviets (UCL Press). Martin McCauley’s Russia 1917-1941 (Sempringham Studies) contains a superb chronology of the period. Orlando Figes and Richard Pipes are the leading modern ‘giants’ in writing about the Russian Revolution.