This topic covers the time America changes from a mainly
rural country to an urban one. Urban interests and politics take over from those
of ‘small-town’ America. It is a time of rapid change, of mass immigration,
of industrial growth, of prosperity (for some) and of increasing tensions in
society. It is also the time America emerges as a Superpower, albeit a reluctant
one.
Vital first steps
It is essential to have a clear chronological understanding
of the period, as well as an understanding of the federal nature of the United
States - what role did the Federal Government play, and what role state and
local governments? What policies did the Republican party adopt, and how were
they different from the Democrats? Which industries grew in the 1920s, and which
faced increasing competition? Although this is a domestic topic it is also
important to consider how America’s relations with the rest of the world
fuelled the Boom, and exacerbated the Slump. Could the Depression have been
avoided, and was its export to the rest of the world, apart from the Soviet
Union, inevitable?
Fundamental issues
(a) The Boom. How did the American economy benefit from the First World War?
Why were the 1920s such a long period of high growth? Which Americans benefited
from growth? Which didn’t? Why is Henry Ford so important? How did ordinary
Americans manage to pay for the new consumer goods? What part did government
policies play in encouraging growth? Was America truly a free market, or heavily
protected behind tariffs?
(b) Why was Prohibition introduced? What impact did it have? When was it
abolished? Why? Which sectors of society supported Prohibition, and which
opposed it?
(c) Why was immigration such an issue in the USA in the 1920s? Why was
legislation passed limiting the types and numbers of immigrants? How does this
tie in with the ‘Red Scare’ and racism? What was the ‘Scopes Trial’ and
what does it tell us about America at this time? Why were there such divisions
within American society at this time?
(d) Why did Wall Street crash in 1929? What part did the banks play in
events? Who was to blame for the crash? What did Hoover do to try to restore
business confidence? How successful was he?
(e) What was it like to be unemployed in America in the early 1930s? Were
there any government benefits or ‘dole’ as in Britain? How did the
government respond to mass unemployment? Was Hoover to blame for the limited
response by government? How effective was ‘self-help’ in dealing with such a
major crisis? Had the Depression got worse or better by the end of 1932?
High-grade issues
(a) Why were Blacks, farmers, and many unskilled workers largely excluded
from the prosperity of the 1920s? What impact did this eventually have on
economic growth? Did tariffs help or hinder growth? What do events like the
Florida Land Boom of 1925 tell us about the mentality of the time? Why was
demand already faltering in 1928 and 1929? Why, therefore, did share prices
continue to rise?
(b) Why did the ‘noble experiment’ go wrong? How did Prohibition increase
disrespect for the law, and lead to a rapid growth of corruption and organised
crime? Was Prohibition ever enforceable? Why were Americans in favour of
government moral regulation yet so opposed to economic regulation? What does
this tell us about the clash between the old and the new in 1920s’ America?
(c) After welcoming so many immigrants before the First World War why had
attitudes changed in the early 1920s? Why were some immigrants seen as ‘troublemakers’?
Why were Sacco and Vanzetti found guilty and executed? In which parts of the
country were the Ku Klux Klan most influential? Why was this? How did this lead
to many Blacks moving north to the industrial cities?
(d) Was it inevitable that the Wall Street Crash led on to a major
depression? Why did the Depression affect the whole country - urban/rural,
farming/industry, east/west? Did the response of imposing more tariffs help or
hinder?
(e) Could the government have done more to alleviate the Depression?
Conventional political wisdom suggested fiscal prudence and lower taxes would
solve the problem - did policies such as these restore confidence? What chance
did Hoover have in the 1932 Presidential election? Why was Roosevelt able to
restore confidence so quickly? What policies did he adopt to try to ‘beat’
the Depression? Did he ‘beat’ the Depression?
Further Reading: There are plenty of books about this crucial
period in America’s history. You might like to try the following to begin
with: D. and S. Willoughby, America 1919-1945, Heinemann Advanced
History; Peter Clement Prosperity, Depression and the New Deal, Hodder
Access to History; Derrick Murphy et al United States 1776-1992
(Chapters 5 and 6), Collins Flagship History; M.J. Heale Franklin D Roosevelt
(Chapter 2), Lancaster Pamphlets; Patrick Renshaw, The Longman Companion to
America in the Era of Two World Wars, 1910-1945, Longman.